The Dark Web: He Hired an Assassin to Kill His Wife

Imagine diving into the dark web to hire an assassin to kill your spouse. It sounds like something out of a crime novel, but for Steven Allwine, it was a horrifying reality. Behind his seemingly perfect life as a loving husband, father, and respected church leader, Steven was hiding dark secrets that led him down a deadly path. Instead of seeking a divorce, Steven turned to the dark web, hoping to make his wife’s death look like an accident and escape with his reputation intact.

A Picture-Perfect Family—Or So It Seemed

Steven and Amy Allwine appeared to have it all. Married for 18 years, they had a 9-year-old adopted son and successful careers. Amy ran a thriving dog training business, and Steven was a freelance IT consultant. They were also deeply involved in their church, with Steven even serving as a preacher. His sermons were so moving that they brought his congregation to tears. But beneath the surface, Steven was living a double life—one filled with lies, betrayal, and an obsession with getting rid of his wife.

The Affair That Led to Murder

It started with an affair. Despite their picture-perfect life, Steven was unhappy in his marriage and turned to the extramarital dating site Ashley Madison, designed for people looking to have affairs. It was there that Steven met Michelle, a woman in her 40s who seemed to be everything his wife wasn’t. While Amy was busy with her career and church responsibilities, Michelle offered Steven comfort and validation. She became the escape he longed for.

But there was a problem: Steven’s ultra-conservative church had strict rules against divorce. If he left Amy, it would destroy his reputation and cost him his leadership role. So instead of ending the marriage, Steven began to plot something far darker.

The Dark Web Assassin Plot

Using his IT skills, Steven accessed the dark web, a hidden part of the internet where illegal activities like drug deals and hitman services are said to thrive. He found a site called Besa Mafia, which claimed to offer services ranging from beatings to assassinations. The site accepted payment in Bitcoin, which Steven believed would make his actions untraceable.

Over the course of several months, Steven exchanged emails with the site’s administrator, “Yura,” planning the murder of his wife, Amy. He paid thousands of dollars in Bitcoin, requesting that the hit look like a car accident or home invasion gone wrong. Each time, Yura delayed the hit, asking for more money while providing excuses as to why the job couldn’t be done.

When the Hitman Fails, Do It Yourself

Frustrated by the repeated delays and mounting costs, Steven finally decided to take matters into his own hands. On November 13, 2016, he called 911, claiming to have found his wife dead from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. He told police that Amy had shot herself while he and their son were out to dinner. At first glance, it seemed like a tragic suicide.

But something didn’t add up. Amy was right-handed, yet the gun was found in her left hand. There were signs that someone had cleaned up blood near the scene, and a toxicology report revealed that Amy had high levels of Scopolamine, a drug known for causing disorientation. The police began to suspect foul play.

The Dark Web Lies Unravel

Steven’s carefully crafted plan quickly fell apart. Investigators discovered his dark web activities, including his communications with Besa Mafia. The site, it turned out, was a scam—there were no real hitmen, just people taking money from desperate individuals like Steven. But all of Steven’s conversations with the site had been leaked, exposing his intentions to kill Amy.

As the investigation deepened, more evidence came to light. Steven had gunshot residue on his hand, and his affair with Michelle provided a clear motive. To make matters worse, police uncovered a Bitcoin address on Steven’s phone that matched the one he had used to pay for the hit. It was undeniable proof that Steven Allwine was the man behind the dark web alias “Dog Day God,” the username he used to orchestrate the murder.

The Verdict

In January 2017, Steven Allwine was arrested for the murder of his wife, Amy. At trial, the evidence was overwhelming. From the dark web messages to the forensic evidence, it was clear that Steven had meticulously planned Amy’s death for months. He was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

A Cautionary Tale of the Dark Web

Steven Allwine’s story is a chilling reminder that the dark web isn’t as hidden as many believe. While Steven thought he could outsmart the system, his actions were ultimately his downfall. His obsession with preserving his reputation and his desire to have Amy killed led him down a dangerous path that ended in tragedy.

In the end, Steven could have chosen a simpler path: divorce. But instead, he chose to delve into the darkest corners of the internet, where he believed he could hire someone to do the unthinkable. His ego, desperation, and belief that he could get away with murder destroyed not only his life but the lives of those around him.

Conclusion

The dark web might seem like a place where anything is possible, but as Steven Allwine’s story shows, nothing stays hidden forever. His tragic descent into murder is a stark reminder that no matter how deep you go, the truth always finds a way to surface.